As an experienced real estate investor who has witnessed countless market cycles and navigated the intricacies of tax-advantaged investing, I can confidently assert real estate investing offers superior returns compared to traditional investment vehicles.
While financial advisers routinely recommend diversified portfolios of stocks and bonds, groundbreaking research and decades of tax policy innovations have created a compelling case for making real estate the cornerstone of any serious investment strategy.
Kiplinger’s Adviser Intel, formerly known as Building Wealth, is a curated network of trusted financial professionals who share expert insights on wealth building and preservation. Contributors, including fiduciary financial planners, wealth managers, CEOs and attorneys, provide actionable advice about retirement planning, estate planning, tax strategies and more. Experts are invited to contribute and do not pay to be included, so you can trust their advice is honest and valuable.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more – straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice – straight to your e-mail.
The data speaks: Real estate’s historical dominance
The most comprehensive analysis of investment returns ever conducted, titled The Rate of Return on Everything, 1870-2015, revolutionizes our understanding of asset class performance.
This Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco study examined over 145 years of investment data across major asset classes, revealing findings that challenge conventional wisdom about portfolio allocation.
The research found that residential real estate delivered superior risk-adjusted returns compared to stocks, while demonstrating significantly lower volatility.
Over the entire study period, real estate achieved returns exceeding 8% annually after inflation, outpacing stocks while maintaining half the volatility of equity markets.
This “having your cake and eating it too” scenario represents the holy grail of investing: higher returns with lower risk.
Even when limiting the data to the modern era, post-World War II, real estate continued to demonstrate its superiority. Housing consistently outperformed bonds and Treasuries by substantial margins, while matching or exceeding stock market returns.
This consistency across different economic periods underscores real estate’s fundamental strength as an investment vehicle.
The study’s findings become even more compelling when considering real estate markets remain largely uncorrelated globally, unlike increasingly interconnected stock markets.
This insulation provides additional portfolio protection during market downturns, as property values in different geographic regions don’t move in lockstep like international equity markets tend to do.
The power of leverage: Amplifying returns through strategic financing
While the San Francisco Fed’s study examined unleveraged real estate returns, the true power of real estate investing emerges when incorporating strategic leverage.
Unlike stock market investing, where margin loans carry significant risks and limitations, real estate allows investors to safely amplify returns through mortgage financing.
Consider a property generating 8% annual returns, purchased with 75% financing at 6% interest. The investor’s actual return on invested capital reaches about 14% annually, significantly outpacing what’s achievable in traditional markets without assuming excessive risk.
This leverage advantage remains sustainable because real estate provides steady cash flow to service debt obligations while appreciating in value over time.
Moreover, real estate leverage is non-recourse in most cases, meaning lenders can claim the property itself only if problems arise, protecting investors’ other assets.
This contrasts sharply with margin investing in stocks, where losses can exceed initial investments and trigger devastating margin calls, a phenomenon that can wipe out even the savviest of accredited investors (and the examples of this are many — such as when Long-Term Capital Management collapsed and Credit Suisse’s Archegos Capital Management defaulted).
Tax advantages: The real estate investor’s secret weapon
While pretax returns favor real estate, the post-tax comparison reveals an even more dramatic advantage.
Real estate enjoys numerous tax benefits unavailable to stock and bond investors, creating superior after-tax returns that compound over time.
Annual depreciation deductions shelter rental income from taxation, effectively providing tax-free cash flow during ownership.
This phantom expense reduces taxable income without requiring actual cash outlays, creating an immediate advantage over dividend-paying stocks that generate fully taxable income.
Capital gains treatment provides favorable tax rates upon sale, but real estate’s true tax advantage lies in strategies unavailable to traditional investors.
These preferential treatments transform good pretax returns into exceptional after-tax wealth accumulation.
The 1031 exchange: Deferring taxes to infinity
The most powerful tool in real estate investing remains the Section 1031 like-kind exchange, which allows investors to defer capital gains taxes indefinitely by reinvesting sale proceeds into replacement properties.
This strategy, often called “defer till you die” or “swap till you drop,” enables investors to compound their returns without tax drag, potentially over multiple decades.
Consider an investor who purchases a $200,000 property that appreciates to $400,000 over 10 years. Rather than selling and paying $40,000 in capital gains taxes (assuming a 20% rate), a 1031 exchange allows the entire $400,000 to purchase replacement property.
Over multiple exchange cycles, this tax deferral creates exponential wealth accumulation that’s impossible through traditional investing.
The mathematics are compelling. An investor executing 1031 exchanges every seven years over a 30-year period can accumulate about 40% more wealth than someone paying taxes on each transaction.
This advantage compounds over time, creating generational wealth that far exceeds what’s achievable through traditional buy-and-hold stock investing.
Multiple exchanges magnify this benefit. Sophisticated investors often execute three to five exchanges over their investing careers, each time upgrading to larger, more valuable properties while deferring substantial tax obligations.
The stepped-up basis provision means heirs inherit these properties at fair market value, permanently eliminating the deferred tax liability.
Qualified opportunity zones: Accelerating after-tax returns
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) in 2017 created qualified opportunity zones (QOZs), offering additional advantages for real estate investors willing to invest in designated economically distressed areas.
These zones provide a pair of distinct tax benefits that further enhance real estate’s appeal.
First, investors can defer capital gains taxes from any source by investing proceeds into QOZ properties, providing flexibility beyond traditional 1031 exchanges. (Current law defers these capital gains taxes until December 31, 2026, although proposed legislation may extend that deadline.)
In addition, and even more significantly, any appreciation within the QOZ investment itself becomes permanently tax-free if held for 10 years.
These benefits stack with traditional real estate advantages, creating unprecedented after-tax return potential. An investor might defer $100,000 in stock market gains by purchasing QOZ real estate, then eliminate taxes entirely on any property appreciation through the 10-year provision.
Risk-adjusted performance: The true measure of investment success
Superior returns mean little without considering risk, where real estate demonstrates additional advantages over traditional investments.
Real estate provides multiple income streams — rental income, appreciation, tax benefits and principal paydown through tenant payments — creating diversification within a single asset class.
Market volatility affects real estate less dramatically than stocks. While stock prices can fluctuate 20% to 30% annually, real estate values typically move more gradually, providing stability for long-term wealth building.
This stability proves particularly valuable for investors approaching retirement who cannot afford significant portfolio volatility.
Real estate also provides inflation protection unavailable in bonds or fixed-income investments. As costs rise, rental income and property values typically increase proportionally, maintaining purchasing power over time.
This inflation hedge becomes increasingly valuable when traditional “safe” investments fail to preserve wealth. (There’s a longer conversation to be had about whether U.S. Treasuries still constitute a “safe” investment as the national debt spirals over $37 trillion … but that’s for another article.)
Implementation strategy: Building a real estate-centric portfolio
Successful real estate investing requires systematic implementation rather than sporadic property purchases. Start with investment-grade rental properties in stable markets with strong rental demand and consistent appreciation patterns.
Focus on properties generating positive cash flow from day one while offering appreciation potential.
Looking for expert tips to grow and preserve your wealth? Sign up for Adviser Intel (formerly known as Building Wealth), our free, twice-weekly newsletter.
For accredited investors seeking to begin or expand their real estate portfolios, Delaware statutory trusts (DSTs) provide an excellent entry point into institutional-grade properties.
DSTs allow investors to acquire fractional ownership in high-quality commercial real estate assets — such as Class A office buildings, retail centers or multifamily complexes — that would typically require millions of dollars to purchase individually.
These professionally managed investments provide access to premium properties with experienced operators handling day-to-day management responsibilities.
Importantly, DST interests qualify as replacement properties for 1031 exchanges, enabling investors to defer capital gains while transitioning from hands-on property management to passive real estate ownership.
Gradually scale the portfolio through strategic acquisitions, utilizing both cash flow and periodic refinancing to fund expansion. Execute 1031 exchanges when properties reach optimal sale timing, typically every seven to 10 years, to defer taxes and upgrade holdings.
Consider diversification across property types and geographic markets to minimize risk while maximizing return potential.
Single-family rentals, small multifamily properties and commercial real estate each offer unique advantages depending on market conditions and investor expertise, and all can be acquired individually, or as part of a DST investment.
Conclusion: The evidence-based case for real estate superiority
The combination of superior historical returns, favorable leverage opportunities, exceptional tax advantages and lower volatility creates an overwhelming case for real estate-centric investment strategies.
Academic research confirms real estate’s historical outperformance while demonstrating lower risk characteristics compared to traditional investments.
Strategic use of 1031 exchanges amplifies these advantages by eliminating tax drag over multiple investment cycles, enabling wealth accumulation impossible through traditional approaches.
DSTs can improve returns even more, by enabling investors to upgrade the quality of their holdings even while throttling back on day-to-day property management.
QOZs provide additional acceleration for investors willing to target specific geographic areas.
While past performance provides no guarantee of future results, the fundamental drivers of real estate’s superiority — limited supply, consistent demand, leverage availability and preferential tax treatment — remain intact.
These structural advantages suggest real estate’s outperformance will continue benefiting knowledgeable investors who understand how to harness these powerful wealth-building tools.
The data is clear: Real estate investing, enhanced by strategic tax planning through 1031 exchanges, Delaware statutory trusts and opportunity zone investments, offers superior risk-adjusted returns compared to traditional investment alternatives.
Investors seeking optimal long-term wealth accumulation should seriously consider making real estate the foundation of their investment strategy.
