But the proposal also turns a blind eye to the heavy government spending and ballooning deficits that have riled up bond investors in recent weeks. Treasury yields are at multiyear highs, and the 10-year is flirting with the psychologically critical 5% level. Fixed-income traders are bristling at the lack of attention being paid to the fiscal situation.
Ultimately, what’s being branded as affordability relief for households could make government-level affordability issues even worse.
The bond-market stakes
Let’s do some quick back-of-the-envelope math. If 240 million adult citizens get $5,000 apiece, that comes out to $1.2 trillion. Add that to the US’s already-record-high $40 trillion national debt.
If government spending is actually a concern, the administration appears to be moving in the wrong direction. Even if a cash injection helps in the short term, higher borrowing costs will hurt everyday Americans in the long run, especially at a time when they’re already sensitive to affordability.
Interestingly enough, Treasury yields barely budged late Wednesday night when Trump first floated the dividend. The (lack of) reaction suggests bond traders see a low likelihood that the nationwide payouts will actually occur.
The affordability test
It’s also still unclear who would qualify, when payments would arrive, or how the government plans to cover the costs. The lack of detail also helps explain why Treasury yields barely moved on the announcement.
But the calculus for investors could change quickly if the plan gathers momentum. While a $5,000 check would be an affordability boost for millions of families, it won’t lower the price of oil, reduce the government’s borrowing needs, or reassure investors about inflation. In fact, all three concerns could be heightened.
It highlights a catch-22 facing the Trump administration: The quickest affordability fix could make the underlying problems harder to solve.
